Monday 26 November 2012

Sports Personality 2012 - Who's deserving of the shortlist

Today the BBC released the 12 member shortlist for Sports Personality of the Year 2012, the list includes 8 Olympians, 3 Paralympians and a Golfer. Clearly however, some are much more deserving of their place than others.

Nicola Adams - The very first female Olympic boxing champion on this planet; not only did she win a gold medal, she won it in style in front of a screaming crowd at the ExCeL. On top of her sporting achievments she came out as bisexual, suggesting how much her sport has moved on this year.

Ben Ainslie - The most successful sailor in Olympic history, although I doubt his ability to achieve any of the three Sports Personality trophies, he has definitely shown himself as an incredible British Olympian over the last 16 years.

Jessica Ennis - If this girl wasn't on the list I would have sent a strongly worded letter to the BBC demanding that she be put on the shortlist. She was undoubtedly the face of the games both before and after, she united an entire nation in a state of ecstasy when she won gold. On top of all of that she ran the hurdles in a time that would have won the 2008 Olympic Gold in 100m Hurdles. I fully expect this girl to achieve one of the three trophies this year, whether it will be better than her third places from 2009 and 2010, we will have to wait and see.

Mo Farah - The only British Olympian of 2012 to have won two individual gold medals and the first Brit ever to win Olympic Gold in the 5k or 10k. Furthermore he got the entire planet doing the Mobot, including Usain Bolt, this man is truly something and will almost definitely win something on the night.

Katherine Grainger - And now for a change of mood: don't get me wrong, it was incredible to see her finally win Olympic gold after three consecutive silvers, but this year she won a single gold, as a member of a team: Yet Anna Watkins nor 3 double gold medallists are nowhere to be found on the list. I think her chances of an award are low, she is very unknown to non-Olympic fanatics and her achievements are mediocre in comparison to many others.

Sir Chris Hoy - Britain's Greatest Olympian of All Time. Enough Said.

Sarah Storey - It is so great to see Paralympians on the shortlist this year, not only is she one of this Nation's best Paralympians, she is also one of the nations best cyclists: her ability matches that of our Olympians and very nearly got her onto the Olympic squad. Let's not look at all of the 'What ifs' though, she won 4 Paralympic Golds.

David Weir -  Briefly the first suggested 'David' on Google search, but still proud owner of 4 London 2012 Paralympic Gold Medals. Many were amazed to see what this man could do, more were speechless about his incredible ability to keep going for more.

Rory McIlroy - From the heights of human endeavour to the lows of laziness in sport. In the year 2012 this man won a single competition worth winning, instead of training to the degree he should he is more interested in partying with his girlfriend, Caroline Wozniacki (another overrated sportsperson). Furthermore, should the BBC give an award to a man who is threatening to compete for Ireland in Rio 2016?

Ellie Simmonds - The teenage swimming superstar won 4 Paralympic medals this year; 2 of them gold. Her attitude to competition was incredible this year; while the media was moaning about Victoria Arlen's classification she celebrated the competition she recieved from racing the American of a similar age to her. She definitely has the Personality for this award, as well as sporting achievement to back it up.

Andy Murray - Every year I moan that this man has reahed the shortlist yet again, but not this year; he won Olympic Gold, Olympic Silver, the US Open and reached the final of Wimbledon (and gave Federer a run for his money). He is definitely one of my sporting heroes of 2012 and has definitely changed a few minds.

Bradley Wiggins - Finally, to round off the 12 for 2012 is Britain's first ever winner of the Tour de France, and one of the most decorated British Olympians there are. To say this man is incredible is an understatement. He is definitely a contender for the trophy but most of the people shortlisted are.

Overall I agree with the list; although it seems to be lacking Charlotte Dujardin, Jason Kenny and Laura Trott, each of whom won 2 gold medals in London. I strongly disagree with the inclusion of Rory McIlroy for his mediocre year in comparison with the incredible year some of our Olympians and Paralympians have had.

No comments:

Post a Comment